Supreme Court Rules Accidental Gunshot from Own Weapon Eligible for War Injury Pension
The Supreme Court has ruled that accidental gunshot injuries sustained by Army personnel from their own weapons during operational duty are eligible for the War Injury Element pension. The court directed the government to grant the benefit to a retired Subedar Major.
n a significant ruling, the Supreme Court of India has determined that an accidental gunshot injury sustained by an Army personnel from their own weapon during operational duty is eligible for the War Injury Element of a pension. The verdict offers relief to military veterans and clarifies the criteria for pension benefits.
Information was available with The Chenab Times that a Bench comprising Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice N Kotiswar Singh stated that the origin of the bullet cannot solely dictate whether a wound was self-inflicted. The court allowed an appeal filed by a retired Army Subedar Major, who had been denied this benefit by the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) in May 2023.
The apex court directed the Union government to grant the War Injury Element to the appellant, ex-Subedar Major and Honorary Lieutenant Devi Singh, from his date of retirement. This is to be implemented after adjusting any Disability Element already disbursed. The court mandated that a revised Pension Payment Order and any resultant arrears must be issued within a period of three months from the date of the order, which was passed on November 20.
The Supreme Court underscored that an injury should not be categorized as self-inflicted merely because the projectile was discharged from the serviceman’s own firearm. The exclusion of self-inflicted injuries, the Bench clarified, does not encompass every accidental injury where an individual’s own weapon is involved.
The AFT had previously accepted that the appellant’s disability, which resulted from a gunshot injury on August 7, 2002, in Jammu and Kashmir during Operation Rakshak, was attributable to his military service. However, the Tribunal had dismissed his claim for the War Injury Element pension. This dismissal was primarily based on the AFT’s assertion that the requisite final Battle Casualty Certificate had not been issued by the competent authority, identified as the Adjutant General’s Branch/MP-5.
At the time of his release, the Release Medical Board had assessed the appellant’s disability at 40% for life. Consequently, the Army had granted him only the ordinary Disability Element of his pension. His subsequent plea for the enhanced War Injury Element was rejected by the AFT, with the Tribunal citing the absence of final Battle Casualty approval from the competent authority and his name not appearing in the relevant digital database.
In its judgment, the Supreme Court set aside the AFT’s order. The apex court observed that the appellant’s absence from a digital database, which was created at a later stage, served merely as an absence of further corroboration. It was not, the court emphasized, affirmative evidence capable of disproving contemporaneous and signed official records that had survived. Therefore, the appellant should not be made to suffer for circumstances beyond his control, the court stated.
The ruling highlights a critical aspect of military service compensation, ensuring that accidental injuries incurred during duty, even if from one’s own weapon, are recognized appropriately. The judgment underscores the importance of official records and the principle that veterans should not be deprived of rightful benefits due to procedural or administrative oversights, particularly when contemporaneous evidence supports their claims.
Did you enjoy this article?
Recommend it — Standard Reader surfaces well-loved writing to more readers across the network.