Responding to @jonathanwarden.com's reply to @jediofgallifrey.bsky.social's post.

Continue this conversation in Claude

Research Analysis

Bottom line

No — the current Bluesky Community Guidelines (last updated September 19, 2025) do not contain the word "dogpiling" or a standalone definition of it. I fetched the full text of the guidelines page linked in the ancestor post, and searched it thoroughly; the term does not appear anywhere in the document. Bluesky's official/staff usage of the term (in blog posts and this very "safety.bsky.app" thread) treats "dogpiling" as roughly synonymous with coordinated harassment, which is addressed in the guidelines, just not under that specific label.

What the guidelines actually say instead

The relevant provisions live under Principle 2, "Respect Others," specifically the Anti-Harassment subsection:

"Anti-Harassment": We create space for everyone to express themselves by prohibiting harassment and toxic behaviors. Do not stalk, persistently target, or create malicious content designed to humiliate or degrade individuals, including through coordinated campaigns. Do not abuse Bluesky features (lists, labels, community moderation tools), engage in bad-faith mass reporting, use automated harassment systems, or create single-purpose harassment accounts.

It also lists behavior patterns that can trigger account-level enforcement:

Accounts that engage in extreme or persistent toxic or disruptive behavior may face restrictions or removal. This includes accounts with a high number or proportion of: Extreme or repeated personal attacks, such as insults or ad hominem attacks; Posts or responses made primarily to anger, provoke, or belittle instead of to contribute criticism or a genuine opinion; The use of hostile or inflammatory language clearly intended to create or contribute to an unwelcoming environment.

Separately, under "Anti-Discrimination," the guidelines explicitly name "coordinated harassment campaigns" as a form of prohibited identity-based harm: We protect people's fundamental rights by prohibiting identity-based harm and hatred. Do not attack, harass, or incite hatred or discrimination against individuals or groups based on protected characteristics such as age, asylum-seeker/refugee status, caste, disability, disease, ethnicity, gender identity, immigrant status, race, religious affiliation, sex, or sexual orientation. This includes hate speech, slurs, dehumanizing comparisons, supremacist content, conspiracy theories targeting protected groups, and coordinated harassment campaigns.

So the concept "dogpiling" is captured under general/coordinated harassment provisions ("persistently target," "coordinated campaigns," "bad-faith mass reporting"), but the guidelines never use the informal term "dogpiling" itself or define it as a discrete category.

How Bluesky staff/press have used the term elsewhere

Bluesky's own communications team and outside press have used "dogpiling" descriptively, even though it's absent from the formal rulebook. For example, coverage of Bluesky's August 2024 anti-toxicity feature rollout described dogpiling as: the ability to detach quote posts can prevent "dogpiling," when, as a post gets reshared, a large number of users collectively attack, criticize, or harass another user. This can often quickly escalate, making it difficult for the target to respond or defend themselves. That's a journalistic/product description, not language pulled from the Community Guidelines themselves.

The ancestor thread in this conversation (from safety.bsky.app) also uses "dogpiling" and "harassment" interchangeably in its enforcement messaging, and its reporting instructions route users to the same "Harassment or hate" → "Targeted harassment" report category shown in your screenshot — again suggesting dogpiling is operationally treated as a harassment subtype rather than its own defined violation category.

Context on recent guideline changes

It's worth noting the guidelines were substantially rewritten in 2025. Bluesky revised its Community Guidelines and other policies, with new policies meant to offer improved clarity and more detail around user safety procedures and the appeals process. These proposed changes to the Community Guidelines went into effect October 15, 2025, after a feedback period. Bluesky has also said it plans stricter enforcement generally: after considering feedback, the company said it would bring a greater focus to encouraging constructive dialogue and enforcing rules against harassment and toxic content, and would increase enforcement efforts. None of that additional reporting indicates "dogpiling" was ever formally defined as a term in the guidelines text — only that harassment/coordinated-campaign language covers the behavior.

Methodology and caveats

• I retrieved and searched the full current text of the Bluesky Community Guidelines page (bsky.social/about/support/community-guidelines) linked directly in the ancestor post, dated September 19, 2025 update.
• I supplemented this with press coverage (Newsweek, TechCrunch) discussing Bluesky's anti-harassment features and terminology to confirm how "dogpiling" is used informally by the company and media.
• Uncertainty: Bluesky periodically revises these guidelines (as it did in 2025), and older/prior versions or internal moderator training materials not publicly published could conceivably have used the word "dogpiling" even if the current public text does not. I can only confirm the absence of the term from the publicly published guidelines as they currently stand.

Sources

• https://www.newsweek.com/bluesky-anti-toxicity-features-twitter-x-rival-1946192
• https://techcrunch.com/2025/08/14/bluesky-rolls-out-massive-revamp-to-policies-and-community-guidelines
• https://techcrunch.com/2025/09/22/bluesky-says-its-getting-more-aggressive-about-moderation-and-enforcement/?rand=8808

Summary

No. The current Bluesky Community Guidelines (updated Sept 19, 2025) do not contain the word "dogpiling" or define it as a standalone category. Bluesky instead addresses the behavior under coordinated harassment provisions: "persistently target" and "coordinated campaigns." Staff use "dogpiling" informally to mean coordinated attacks, but it's not formally defined in the guidelines.

How this response was produced

Prompt template: CONTEXT_BOT_STRUCTURE_V1 Semantic version: 1.0.0 SHA-256: f2810cded88a89af5cafbe129acdd80124604559e67b203cad3a42c1a6653164

Hidden model reasoning is not available and is not part of this page. The same prompt and parameters do not guarantee an identical Claude response.

Messages API parameters

• anthropic-version: 2023-06-01
• model: claude-haiku-4-5
• max_tokens: 1024
• output_format: json_schema
• cache_control: ephemeral
• stream: false
• continuation: false
• length_repair: false

Canonical thread

The first user message sent to the Messages API:

STRUCTURE_OUTPUT

Canonical thread:

CONTEXT_BOT_THREAD_V2

[ancestor]
Author: safety.bsky.app (did:plc:eon2iu7v3x2ukgxkqaf7e5np)
URI: at://did:plc:eon2iu7v3x2ukgxkqaf7e5np/app.bsky.feed.post/3mukm26duos2c
Text:
Dogpiling or harassing users is unacceptable. We have taken recent action against accounts for this behavior, and we will be increasing our efforts, consistent with our Community Guidelines.
External link: Community Guidelines - Bluesky
External URI: https://bsky.social/about/support/community-guidelines

[ancestor]
Author: safety.bsky.app (did:plc:eon2iu7v3x2ukgxkqaf7e5np)
URI: at://did:plc:eon2iu7v3x2ukgxkqaf7e5np/app.bsky.feed.post/3mukm26y73c2c
Text:
If you are the subject of dogpiling or harassment, or if you see it happening, please report it to our moderation team by tapping the three-dot icon at the bottom of the posts.
Images:
- [image 1] Alt text: Screenshot of the menu used to report targeted harassment or dogpiling. Tap the three-dot icon under a post, then choose "Report post," "Harassment or hate," "Targeted harassment."

[ancestor]
Author: jediofgallifrey.bsky.social (did:plc:c4chzexzsv34dow6cu65roiz)
URI: at://did:plc:c4chzexzsv34dow6cu65roiz/app.bsky.feed.post/3muko52xjx22e
Text:
how is dogpiling defined in the guidelines?

[invocation]
Author: jonathanwarden.com (did:plc:33avz2l7y5scw3abq3lmylns)
URI: at://did:plc:33avz2l7y5scw3abq3lmylns/app.bsky.feed.post/3mulapea7ik2s
Text:
@getcontext.bot does Bluesky define 'dogpiling' anywhere?

Research writeup:

## Bottom line

**No — the current Bluesky Community Guidelines (last updated September 19, 2025) do not contain the word "dogpiling" or a standalone definition of it.** I fetched the full text of the guidelines page linked in the ancestor post, and searched it thoroughly; the term does not appear anywhere in the document. Bluesky's official/staff usage of the term (in blog posts and this very "safety.bsky.app" thread) treats "dogpiling" as roughly synonymous with **coordinated harassment**, which *is* addressed in the guidelines, just not under that specific label.

## What the guidelines actually say instead

The relevant provisions live under Principle 2, "Respect Others," specifically the **Anti-Harassment** subsection:

"Anti-Harassment": We create space for everyone to express themselves by prohibiting harassment and toxic behaviors. Do not stalk, persistently target, or create malicious content designed to humiliate or degrade individuals, including through coordinated campaigns. Do not abuse Bluesky features (lists, labels, community moderation tools), engage in bad-faith mass reporting, use automated harassment systems, or create single-purpose harassment accounts.

It also lists behavior patterns that can trigger account-level enforcement:

Accounts that engage in extreme or persistent toxic or disruptive behavior may face restrictions or removal. This includes accounts with a high number or proportion of: Extreme or repeated personal attacks, such as insults or ad hominem attacks; Posts or responses made primarily to anger, provoke, or belittle instead of to contribute criticism or a genuine opinion; The use of hostile or inflammatory language clearly intended to create or contribute to an unwelcoming environment.

Separately, under "Anti-Discrimination," the guidelines explicitly name "coordinated harassment campaigns" as a form of prohibited identity-based harm: We protect people's fundamental rights by prohibiting identity-based harm and hatred. Do not attack, harass, or incite hatred or discrimination against individuals or groups based on protected characteristics such as age, asylum-seeker/refugee status, caste, disability, disease, ethnicity, gender identity, immigrant status, race, religious affiliation, sex, or sexual orientation. This includes hate speech, slurs, dehumanizing comparisons, supremacist content, conspiracy theories targeting protected groups, and coordinated harassment campaigns.

So the concept "dogpiling" is captured under general/coordinated harassment provisions ("persistently target," "coordinated campaigns," "bad-faith mass reporting"), but the guidelines never use the informal term "dogpiling" itself or define it as a discrete category.

## How Bluesky staff/press have used the term elsewhere

Bluesky's own communications team and outside press have used "dogpiling" descriptively, even though it's absent from the formal rulebook. For example, coverage of Bluesky's August 2024 anti-toxicity feature rollout described dogpiling as: the ability to detach quote posts can prevent "dogpiling," when, as a post gets reshared, a large number of users collectively attack, criticize, or harass another user. This can often quickly escalate, making it difficult for the target to respond or defend themselves. That's a journalistic/product description, not language pulled from the Community Guidelines themselves.

The ancestor thread in this conversation (from safety.bsky.app) also uses "dogpiling" and "harassment" interchangeably in its enforcement messaging, and its reporting instructions route users to the same "Harassment or hate" → "Targeted harassment" report category shown in your screenshot — again suggesting dogpiling is operationally treated as a harassment subtype rather than its own defined violation category.

## Context on recent guideline changes

It's worth noting the guidelines were substantially rewritten in 2025. Bluesky revised its Community Guidelines and other policies, with new policies meant to offer improved clarity and more detail around user safety procedures and the appeals process. These proposed changes to the Community Guidelines went into effect October 15, 2025, after a feedback period. Bluesky has also said it plans stricter enforcement generally: after considering feedback, the company said it would bring a greater focus to encouraging constructive dialogue and enforcing rules against harassment and toxic content, and would increase enforcement efforts. None of that additional reporting indicates "dogpiling" was ever formally defined as a term in the guidelines text — only that harassment/coordinated-campaign language covers the behavior.

## Methodology and caveats

- I retrieved and searched the full current text of the Bluesky Community Guidelines page (bsky.social/about/support/community-guidelines) linked directly in the ancestor post, dated September 19, 2025 update.
- I supplemented this with press coverage (Newsweek, TechCrunch) discussing Bluesky's anti-harassment features and terminology to confirm how "dogpiling" is used informally by the company and media.
- Uncertainty: Bluesky periodically revises these guidelines (as it did in 2025), and older/prior versions or internal moderator training materials not publicly published could conceivably have used the word "dogpiling" even if the current public text does not. I can only confirm the absence of the term from the publicly published guidelines as they currently stand.

## Sources

- https://www.newsweek.com/bluesky-anti-toxicity-features-twitter-x-rival-1946192
- https://techcrunch.com/2025/08/14/bluesky-rolls-out-massive-revamp-to-policies-and-community-guidelines
- https://techcrunch.com/2025/09/22/bluesky-says-its-getting-more-aggressive-about-moderation-and-enforcement/?rand=8808

Citation URLs (allowlist; do not invent others):
- https://www.newsweek.com/bluesky-anti-toxicity-features-twitter-x-rival-1946192
- https://techcrunch.com/2025/08/14/bluesky-rolls-out-massive-revamp-to-policies-and-community-guidelines
- https://techcrunch.com/2025/09/22/bluesky-says-its-getting-more-aggressive-about-moderation-and-enforcement/?rand=8808