Skip to content

Technology & Creativity: Why We Love Hatsune Miku and Hate GenAI

Why GenAI is much worse than "just a tool", and on the value of art and expression.

ike all of human society, art has always been in a bidirectional relationship with technology. Art can inspire technological innovation, and technological innovations can enable art forms. Art can reinforce a perspective that is critical of new technological trends, and new technological trends can hinder and critically harm the arts.

Let's first take a quick look at some examples of what I mean:

  • Art -> Technology: Star Trek had mobile communicators before we had mobile phones.
  • Technology -> Art: Computers, and eventually drawing tablets, enabled artists to draw in software, giving them quality of life features, such as CTRL-Z, layers, and digital blending brushes.
  • Art -> Technology: The cautionary tale of the Palantir in Lord of the Rings inspires Peter Thiel to create mass surveillance software.
  • Technology -> Art: Drone warfare becomes a means of devastating civilian areas from the comfort of a remote base, removing inhibitions humans have to killing people, inspiring the band Muse to make a concept album that is critical of drones as technology.

Technology per se in a double edged sword. One always has to consider the implications a technology has on society. And like I mentioned before, art is a part of human society.

I will go a step further and say that art is a critical element of the human experience. In a way it is enabled and endangered by automation. Only when we moved from hunters and gatherers who were always preoccupied with surviving to farmers who employed agriculture have we found more and more time to develope what is colloquially known as culture. If we were developmentally still in our earlier stages of human life, we would not have art. There simply would not have been time for it. But once we had it, it became impossible to take it away from us. We depend on stimulation: entertainment that only human made art can provide to bring us the emotional food that we need. Culture is a basic need that we have. It may not be as urgent as our need to breathe oxygen or eat food or drink water, but it still is really important, or else we become more depressed, cynical, violent, and non-selfreflecting. Art carries the burden of communicating urgent needs for change. It is a reflection of the current crises. The worries and fears, but also the joys that shape our emotions get expressed as art. Be it poetry, music, sculpture, imagery, motion picture, comedy, drama, whatever. Art has something to say, and there is a need for things to be said.

Ok that was a lot of waxing poetic about art as a concept. Point is: it is important and we cannot live without it.

I speak to you as a creative person and a member of human society. I am graphical artist and musician. I did some 3d modelling and rendering, I do a lot of music production, I create creative software. Certain things I do creatively are only possible because of technological advancements of the last 60 years.

Why do we creative people love certain technology, like Hatsune Miku, Minecraft, and drawing tablets, and hate GenAI? If you are not in our artist bubble, you might think this perspective to be hypocritical, but I will go far into the details here on why it is not hypocritical at all; how some technology enables us creatively, and some threatens us existentially. How some will bring joy and some will bring societal doom.

This is not going to be a full comprehensive list of all the reasons genAI is awful and must be banned, but off the top of my dome, let me remind you of a few things:

  • New technology is a tradeoff; what are its advantages versus its problems?
  • GenAI plagiarizes; attribution is massively important to artists, as it is the major factor of discovery of an artist. GenAI does not create new artworks, it only regurgitates existing artwork that is stolen from unconsenting artists.
  • GenAI pollutes and boils the planet, and poisons our water supplies; this is just a fact of AI datacenters. Plus there are so many datacenters already, there is simply zero benefit to building more of them. And no, this does not compare at all to other uses of the internet, as those are way less resource intensive or way more beneficial. By prompting Chat-GPT instead of a simple web search you are multiplying your ecological footprint insanely much. And image generation is even way worse.
  • GenAI omits personality and meaning from artwork, making it unusable as emotional food; The youtuber game developer Juniper Dev recently made a compelling video about the threat of GenAI to the video game industry, in which she points out that GenAI will never be able to fill the hole that gamers actually have. Due to the lack of personality and meaning in stolen plagiarized slop work, it will not satisfy our need of entertainment, and our need to be challenged.
  • It is known that GenAI makes its users measurably less cognitively powerful. Yes, just ten minutes of GenAI usage are enough to make you noticably more stupid.
  • GenAI output is genuinely less qualitative. AI flyers and logos all look bad, without exceptions.
  • Despite that, there is a massive amount of people who brainwashed themselves into thinking that they will be able to live with an AI generated culture. And this harms artists, costs them their jobs. Managers are greedy. They look at the cost of hiring human employees and say, no thank you. There are several creative disciplines that are severely threatened and impacted this day: video game developers are being laid off in masses by many major gaming labels, media uses more and more genAI assets rather than paying artists to create actually valuable pieces of art for them. The culture we consume is poisoned, because of greedy corporations, who think they can get away with ai generating a tv commercial spot for them. We, who have to watch these bad horrible ai slop tv ads, have to suffer, because the execs cannot sustain their infinite greed. This kills creative jobs.
  • And it is not just creative jobs that are threatened; support call center jobs are already extinct and were one of the biggest minimum wage jobs out there. And the execs are looking to replace all of white collar workers with inferior genAI.

So here's what's up: every technology is a tradeoff, and as we see in the bullet points, genAI has massive negative effects on human society as a whole without providing a single benefit.

We can apply this tradeoff thinking to other products of technology, and see that instead of eating up jobs, they created way more jobs.

Let's talk about Hatsune Miku! For decades, she has been an absolute icon in the internet world. At the surface level, she seems like a negative deal: She is a virtual singer, so does she steal the jobs of traditional singers? No, because Hatsune Miku and traditional singers do different things.

  • Vocaloid voice banks have such distinctive robotic tones, that they simply do not compete in the same area. Yes there is some overlap; Cher has used vocoders and such in her music to achieve a robotic sound to her voice, and some artists intentionally employ auto tune to quantize their voice into really discrete steps that therefore also sound robotic. But still, there is demand for both. Vocaloid did not decrease demand for singers; in fact it influenced many singers! Some producers started out with vocaloid vocals and then switched to singing themselves when they found the confidence.
  • Hatsune Miku and other Vocaloids require human creative work, much like singing is itself. Instead of singing yourself, you need to tune the voice bank. It's a whole science with a learning curve, just like singing. It is therefore not a shortcut, but just a different means of expression.
  • Hatsune Miku inspired arts in many many other creative fields; visual arts, cosplay, anime, there's a Miku for everything and everyone.

I wanna talk about a bit of a stealthy proto elephant that is approaching the room though. Unfortunately, Miku is also a corpo product in a sense, and therefore not safe from being infiltrated by AI garbage features. Apparently FL Studio recently added a GenAI support agent to their software. This same fate can also unfortunately befall Miku at some point. But so far, we are safe for now. In fact, Miku is currently on tour in Europe. With her Miku Expo, she is heralding the works of other producers utilizing the voicebanks, and touring with an actual human band. You see how this is a case of technology benefitting human expression. And how GenAI is the whole opposite of that.

Similar things can be said about synthesizers, electric guitars, guitar pedals, drawing tablets, and all that jazz: it comes down to where jobs are created and where jobs are stolen, and what the general effects of technologies on society are. Technology does not exist in a vacuum. GenAI threatens us all.

Ban GenAI!!

P.S. Two days ago I have submitted a petition to the EU parliament that calls for considering a ban on GenAI. I hope they accept it into their website, I mean I wrote it very politely and with a lot of reasoning behind my perspective. So I am doing my part in the fight against GenAI. Once it is accepted to the website I will share the petition everywhere and I ask every ally against GenAI to share and/or sign it. Together, we can defeat the great evil of GenAI. I will not stand by idly. I fight for us!

Did you enjoy this article?

Recommend it — Standard Reader surfaces well-loved writing to more readers across the network.

Across the AtmosphereDiscussions