Wired Says ‘Please Let The Internet Die.’ Some Of Us Are Busy Building A Better One.
It remains incredible — and disturbing — to me how many people now think of the entire internet as being made up of a few giant enshittifying companies. I understand why that is. The big companies absolutely do dominate much of the internet, and it’s close to impossible to avoid them entirely. But that doesn’t...
t remains incredible — and disturbing — to me how many people now think of the entire internet as being made up of a few giant enshittifying companies. I understand why that is. The big companies absolutely do dominate much of the internet, and it’s close to impossible to avoid them entirely. But that doesn’t mean that that’s the entirety of the internet. And when you act as if it is, you do real damage to the good parts of the internet that still exist outside of the blast radius of those giants.
Five years ago, I wrote an article listing out a bunch of “other” internet websites, in the form of a “test suite” for anyone proposing internet regulations. Since most attempts to regulate the internet focus on the alleged (often not clearly proven) “harms” of one of the internet giants, I wanted people to think through the harm that these rules will do to the actual parts of the internet worth saving. These included forums and smaller shopping sites and web hosting and chat groups and more. It also included Wikipedia, which later picked up on the idea (I was told by someone there that this was partly inspired by my original article) and offered up “The Wikipedia Test.“
And yet, it seems difficult for people to remember this. It’s just so easy to bitch and moan that the internet now is just Meta and Google and Amazon and TikTok and (these days) OpenAI or whatever. And it leads to silly articles like Wired’s recent article Please Let the Internet Die.
But if you read through it, the entire article is about enshittifying internet giants, with the assumption that because they all suck, the rest of the internet should die as well.
Giants including Meta and Google have been forced to settle massive consumer lawsuits brought over privacy violations and mental health harms allegedly caused by the addictive mechanisms of their platforms. Schools are banning smartphones as multiple countries institute social media restrictions for under-16s. Parents are in a panic about their kids aspiring to careers as social media celebrities, losing themselves in a vast ecosystem of online casinos, or joining extremist movements.
Generative AI, briefly considered an amusing novelty, is now a turbocharged slop engine for the web, filling feeds and comment sections with useless, grotesque content. As humans scroll past headlines about AI taking their jobs, confusing fantasy for reality, and contributing to cognitive decline, any consumer appeal the technology might have is turning to anguish. The data centers that power it have become increasingly unpopular, and politically radioactive.
It is ridiculous to conclude that because some giant parts of the internet are enshittifying, there’s little worth saving in the rest of it. But that’s exactly where this article lands.
To be online, many now admit, is to be endlessly manipulated and exploited. In December, Oxford University Press declared rage bait to be the word of the year, noting that use of the term had tripled over the previous 12 months. The lexical spike represented a heightened awareness that monetized social accounts churn out bad-faith takes and extremist content, automating this abusive behavior with generative AI, simply to profit off hostile engagement. Billionaire oligarchs have opened the floodgates to such inauthentic activity, conspiracy-mongering, and hate speech by rolling back moderation.
In short, when you hang around online in 2026, you see little worth saving. Perhaps a decade ago, you felt that the glimmers of community and joy, of artistic and intellectual exchange, were enough to balance out the toxic junk. No longer.
But that’s bullshit. And, annoyingly, the folks at Wired should know that that’s bullshit. There are plenty of interesting parts of the internet that are still providing tremendous value. I’m obviously biased, but everything that’s been happening with ATprotocol in the last year has been incredible. Developers keep jumping in and building genuinely useful stuff — as just one example, an astronomer showed off software that streams time-critical data across the network to alert telescopes to supernovae — because anyone can just build things on open protocols. Just take a look at some of the many recaps of the Atmosphere Conference from earlier this year. People came out of it excited to build a new and better internet.
You can open up any of those links in the last two sentences and read about the excitement and the building, but I’ll just grab a bit from that last link:
The open web of the nineties didn’t win because the tools were better. It won because a critical mass of people decided that the alternative, a handful of AOL-style walled gardens choosing what everyone saw, was not the future they wanted. Then they built their way out of it. Slowly, unglamorously, in rooms that looked a lot like this one.
Whether atproto ends up being the thing, or a stepping stone to the thing, I don’t know. Nobody in the room claimed to know. But the work is real, the apps are shipping, and the people building them are taking it seriously without taking themselves seriously. That combination is rare, and historically, it’s the one that wins.
But if people just accept that “the internet needs to die,” we don’t get there. We get more stupid regulations that lock in those enshittifying giants and make it impossible to build a better internet.
The Wired piece is, in theory, a review of a new book called “The Internet Will Die,” which, at least as Wired presents it, frames the internet as fragile and doomed to cycles of decay, with big companies making things worse and deleting our digital histories along the way:
For one, West argues, people misperceive the “vastness” of the internet, which really amounts to “a vanishing fraction, a rounding error, of the human experience.” Moreover, it is remarkably fragile—West opens with the story of how a 2001 train derailment in a Baltimore tunnel took out a major bundle of fiber-optic cables, leading to internet slowdowns nationwide—and continually undergoes cycles of death and rebirth as a result of this natural instability.
If the internet is much smaller and less solid than imagined, West’s book suggests, then it’s crucial to recognize the forces that determine how those deaths unfold, or which pieces are preserved while others crumble. Because the market has falsely sold us the web as a comprehensive library of accumulated wisdom, each transient phase of this global network comes to define the present, for better and worse. Today we witness a dismal paralysis brought on by algorithmic incentives to churn out inflammatory garbage: Full-time influencers are in a losing arms race for attention with low-effort, high-volume channels that streamline production by delegating the creative process to bleeding-edge software.
But, again, that assumes an internet dominated by a handful of giants, the ones you hand all your data to, is the only internet possible.
But we already know that’s not true and it doesn’t need to be true in the future either. It sounds like West’s framing in his book is to encourage users to be more thoughtful about where they spend their time and energy online — and that’s great — but as Wired frames it, it’s all a wasteful endeavor since it’s always going to suck.
I certainly understand the fatalistic feeling that the internet sucks and will continue to suck. But that’s only true for people who lock themselves into the environments controlled by the internet giants you hate, rather than getting out and looking around at the cool things people are building which put the users in control of their own experience.
The piece ends with the author of the article, Miles Klee, admitting that the author of the book, John West, at least is open to the idea that a better internet can be created. But Klee, a self-described failed composter who’s “too lazy” for the gross work involved, doubts enough people will ever bother to do it.
“Look, the internet is rotting,” West says. “The question is, where are we going to put our energy?” A metaphor he often turns to in his book is compost. “Compost is just rot harnessed for a purpose,” he says. Can a decaying internet be fertilizer for something better? It’s a rosy notion, but speaking as a perennially failed composter—it’s just too gross, and I’m too lazy—I have my doubts about whether enough hardy, patient gardeners can be mobilized to make our digital landscape bloom once more.
And, again, I get the attitude, but I find this self-defeating nihilism to be pointless. The entire point of the internet, as Konstantinos Komaitis reminded us recently, is that it is unfinished. The internet is built on protocols that let anyone come in and build something better. Deciding we should just give up because some of the biggest players now suck is letting enshittification win.
The seeds of a better internet have already been planted. You can join Klee and Wired in doubting that enough gardeners will show up, but plenty of people are already out there digging. Come join us!
Did you enjoy this article?
Recommend it — Standard Reader surfaces well-loved writing to more readers across the network.