Skip to content

🇬🇧 Poststraße 7: Family David Rosenthal

Only three of the nine child­ren in the Rosen­thal fami­ly sur­vi­ved the Holo­caust: Paul and Ella, who mana­ged to escape to Chi­le, and Ernst, who sur­vi­ved depor­ta­ti­on and the libe­ra­ti­on of the so-cal­led “stran­ded train” in April 1945. Their par­ents, David and Regi­ne, and six of their child­ren were mur­de­red in the exter­mi­na­ti­on camps of...

nly three of the nine child­ren in the Rosen­thal fami­ly sur­vi­ved the Holo­caust: Paul and Ella, who mana­ged to escape to Chi­le, and Ernst, who sur­vi­ved depor­ta­ti­on and the libe­ra­ti­on of the so-cal­led “stran­ded train” in April 1945. Their par­ents, David and Regi­ne, and six of their child­ren were mur­de­red in the exter­mi­na­ti­on camps of Ausch­witz and Sobi­bor. Seve­ral spou­ses and grand­child­ren also fell vic­tim to the Nazi geno­ci­de. Here, we focus on the fate of Ernst Rosen­thal as a repre­sen­ta­ti­ve sto­ry of the fami­ly.

Ernst Rosen­thal was born in Ibben­bü­ren on 14 March 1907. His par­ents were David Rosen­thal and Regi­ne, née Epstein, who had been born in Goch, on the Lower Rhi­ne, on 24 April 1874.

Ernst was the fifth of nine child­ren. He had eight siblings: Paul, Har­ry, Her­ta, Hen­ny, Ella, Gre­te, Ilse and Hein­rich. He was also rela­ted to num­e­rous other mem­bers of the exten­ded Rosen­thal fami­ly.

In Ibben­bü­ren, Ernst atten­ded the Pro­tes­tant pri­ma­ry school and later the Catho­lic Rek­to­rats­schu­le, a secon­da­ry school.

From 1922 to 1932, he work­ed main­ly in Ham­burg. He was employ­ed by the Michael­sen com­pa­ny as a win­dow dress­er and sales­man.

In Octo­ber 1932, Ernst was assaul­ted. He retur­ned to Ibben­bü­ren for a few days to report the inci­dent to the poli­ce. He then accept­ed an invi­ta­ti­on from his sis­ter Her­ta and moved to Ams­ter­dam.

A new chap­ter in his life began the­re. On 13 Novem­ber 1935, Ernst Rosen­thal mar­ried Mari­an­ne Pee­per, who had been born in Ams­ter­dam on 17 Novem­ber 1899.

The cou­ple had two child­ren. Their daugh­ter Regi­na, known as Ina, was born in Baarn on 21 Decem­ber 1936. Their son Ger­rit was born in 1939.

A remar­kab­le inci­dent brought the fami­ly to public atten­ti­on in the Net­her­lands.

When Dutch Crown Prin­cess Julia­na gave birth to her daugh­ter Bea­trix, she recei­ved two prams made by the Ger­man com­pa­ny Opel & Küh­ne as gifts.

Julia­na gave one of the­se prams to the mayor of Baarn. She asked him to pass it on to a fami­ly that met cer­tain cri­te­ria: the father had to be Ger­man, the mother Dutch, and the first child had to have been born in Baarn.

The fami­ly of Ernst Rosen­thal matched this descrip­ti­on exact­ly. They the­r­e­fo­re recei­ved one of the prams ori­gi­nal­ly inten­ded for the Dutch Crown Prin­cess.

The sto­ry attrac­ted atten­ti­on in the press. It may later have play­ed a role in the family’s fate.

In 1938, Ernst Rosen­thal went to the Ger­man con­su­la­te in Ams­ter­dam to have his pass­port rene­wed. In front of his eyes, the offi­ci­al docu­ment was torn up.

On 28 Janu­ary 1939, his Ger­man citi­zen­ship was offi­ci­al­ly revo­ked. His pro­per­ty was con­fis­ca­ted at the same time.

The pre­cise reason for this action is unclear. Ernst hims­elf suspec­ted that it was con­nec­ted to com­plaints he had pre­vious­ly filed in Ger­ma­ny. His daugh­ter Ina, howe­ver, belie­ved that the Nazis had been ange­red by the publi­ci­ty sur­roun­ding the pram. A Ger­man gift had been pas­sed on to a Jewish fami­ly.

With the Ger­man occu­pa­ti­on of the Net­her­lands, life beca­me incre­asing­ly dan­ge­rous for Jewish peo­p­le.

In 1943, Ernst Rosen­thal, his wife Mari­an­ne and their two child­ren were depor­ted to Wes­ter­bork. This camp in the north-east of the Net­her­lands ser­ved as a tran­sit camp for the depor­ta­ti­on of Jewish peo­p­le to the exter­mi­na­ti­on camps.

On 5 Febru­ary 1943, the fami­ly was trans­fer­red to Ber­gen-Bel­sen con­cen­tra­ti­on camp. They were held the­re until 7 April 1944.

The fami­ly was even­tual­ly pla­ced in what was known as an exch­an­ge camp. This beca­me pos­si­ble after Marianne’s brot­her paid the Nazis 120,000 guil­ders.

Jewish pri­soners held in the­se exch­an­ge camps were con­side­red poten­ti­al can­di­da­tes for exch­an­ge against Ger­man pri­soners of war or other detai­ned peo­p­le. Con­di­ti­ons were some­ti­mes some­what bet­ter than in other sec­tions of the camps. Nevert­hel­ess, the pri­soners remain­ed at the mer­cy of Nazi per­se­cu­ti­on and vio­lence.

As Bri­tish forces approa­ched in the spring of 1945, thou­sands of pri­soners were loa­ded onto trains and taken out of the exch­an­ge camp. Around 6,800 peo­p­le were affec­ted. They were to be trans­por­ted to ano­ther camp.

Ernst Rosen­thal, his wife and their two child­ren were among tho­se pri­soners.

But their train did not get very far. It came to a halt near Fars­le­ben, clo­se to Mag­de­burg. Pri­soners had thrown so much coal out of the train that it even­tual­ly beca­me impos­si­ble to con­ti­nue the jour­ney.

On 13 April 1945, Ame­ri­can sol­diers rea­ched the train and libe­ra­ted the pri­soners.

The train later beca­me known as the “stran­ded train”. For Ernst Rosen­thal and his fami­ly, libe­ra­ti­on mark­ed the end of a long peri­od of per­se­cu­ti­on, fear and impri­son­ment.

After the war, Ernst retur­ned to the Net­her­lands. In 1953, he beca­me a Dutch citi­zen.

In 1980, he retur­ned to Ibben­bü­ren with his wife at the time. He was plea­sed that peo­p­le from his for­mer home town still reco­g­nis­ed him.

Ernst Rosen­thal died on 18 June 1983 in Alk­maar, in the Net­her­lands.

His life sto­ry tells of a fami­ly torn apart and lar­ge­ly des­troy­ed. But it is also a sto­ry of escape, fami­ly bonds and sur­vi­val under uni­ma­gi­nable con­di­ti­ons.

Ernst Rosen­thal sur­vi­ved Nazi per­se­cu­ti­on. His sto­ry reminds us that behind the names and num­bers of the vic­tims were human beings, with fami­lies, hopes and lives of their own.

Did you enjoy this article?

Recommend it — Standard Reader surfaces well-loved writing to more readers across the network.

Across the AtmosphereDiscussions