Skip to content

JAZZ HANDS

Humour - the mismatch between reality and the window through which we view reality.

Beep Beep
Aug 31, 20259 min read

There’s so much…” he says, holding his hands far apart. Then he reconsiders and moves them closer together. “Well, maybe not that much, but there’s so much stuff in the world.”

She pauses on the realisation that both gestures were completely arbitrary. They communicated no quantity whatsoever, but he’s already moved on, talking as though his impromptu hand-based calibration exercise made perfect sense to her.

I believe that would be absurdist humour, specifically a mixture of anti-humour with deadpan delivery.

The joke is that he makes a big show of correcting himself, as though he’s refining an important measurement, when neither hand gesture represents anything meaningful.

This is my humour, but the problem is that for this to work for other people, the other person must recognise that I know it doesn’t mean anything, and quite often they don’t, they think I’m stupid.

Which, fine, I accept, for from their perspective, it is a perfectly reasonable conclusion. They’ve encountered a man apparently attempting to quantify the contents of the universe with his hands. They’ve no reason to assume they’re witnessing a carefully constructed piece of absurdist anti-humour rather than the early stages of a neurological emergency.

And I can’t explain it to them, because explaining it would ruin it.

“Don’t worry,” I’d have to say. “I’m actually an intelligent person deliberately behaving as though I’m an idiot, and the humour arises from the contrast between the apparent seriousness of my correction and the fundamental meaninglessness of the original gesture.”

At which point I really would be an idiot. An idiot explaining why he’s not an idiot. Which, admittedly, might be funny, but not in the way I’d intended, and this raises a question.

Not a particularly important question. Not compared with climate change or the collapse of Western democracy or the fact that you now need an application on your telephone to park outside a branch of Greggs, but a question nonetheless. – What actually makes something funny?

Is humour a property of the joke? Is it a property of the person hearing the joke? Or does it exist somewhere between the two, like a conversation conducted with Blu-Tack?

Suppose I tell a joke to ten people, nine think I’m an idiot, the tenth understands exactly what I’m doing and finds it hilarious. Was the joke funny?

Nine people say no, one person says yes, democracy has spoken – the joke is not funny, but this seems an unsatisfactory way to judge comedy.

Imagine applying the same principle to music.

Nine people listen to an experimental jazz composition and complain that the musicians appear to be playing different songs simultaneously. The tenth person recognises an extraordinary work of avant-garde improvisation. Is the music bad? Perhaps. Experimental jazz is not automatically good simply because it’s difficult to listen to, but neither is it automatically bad because nine people would rather hear Ed Sheeran perform Baby Shark.

Popularity is evidence of popularity, it’s not necessarily evidence of quality, although I appreciate that this is precisely the sort of argument made by people whose work nobody likes, including, increasingly, me.

Stand-up comedy is impressive when you think about it – to make a career out of making people laugh. One person walks into a room full of strangers and announces, indirectly, “I’ve prepared several opinions about supermarkets, relationships, and public transport, and I’d now like you all to react in unison.” It’s somewhere between performance art and a very confident complaint.

And there is something admirably fragile about observational comedy in particular, because it relies on the belief that everyone has independently noticed the same tiny inconvenience but nobody thought to mention it. A comedian’s job is basically to point at something ordinary and say, “This is weird, isn’t it?” until several hundred people feel represented by a kettle.

Unless it’s Stewart Lee, who will still present you with the comforts of that kettle, but over and over and over again, until you can no longer drink a cup of tea without acute PTSD. He is interesting though, because he has essentially made a career out of a single joke, that joke being that he doesn’t do jokes, and will often begin by expressing bewilderment that anyone has paid to see him, a feeling frequently mirrored by the audience. Which is a shame for his act, because like the Titanic, a good joke is also a great ice-breaker.

“Too soon,” says someone else. Too soon for what, for the joke to become funny?

Was it funny in principle, but not yet authorised for public consumption?

Is there a government department responsible for this, like the Ministry of Appropriate Intervals Between Human Suffering and Light Entertainment?

And if so, how long must we wait? – Three weeks for a minor disaster? Six months for a major one? A full calendar year if the tragedy involved the death of a racist?

Obviously, the answer is more complicated. Also the Titanic sank 114 years ago, so if you think it was too soon, then you need to chill out… the Titanic did.

There’s a psychological theory called benign violation theory, which suggests that humour can arise when something violates our expectations while remaining sufficiently harmless. Or, more precisely, when we perceive the violation as harmless.

And this is the difficulty because the same joke can seem harmless to one person and deeply upsetting to another. Someone directly affected by a tragedy may never find a joke about it funny, but someone else, equally affected, might start making jokes before the ambulance has arrived, not out of callousness, but because sometimes humour is the only available response to something so appalling that ordinary language becomes inadequate.

The bombs are falling, the buildings are collapsing, everything you recognise as normal is disintegrating around you, and someone says, “Well, that’s the council tax going up.”

It’s a ridiculous observation, for the council tax is not the primary concern, – obviously a rational person will focus on the threat that newly available open space will attract a new B&Ms store.

But for one moment, the person making the joke has done something extraordinary – they’ve stepped outside the horror. They’ve treated an unbearable situation as though it were a minor administrative inconvenience. They’ve made the catastrophe ridiculous, and although they can’t control the catastrophe, they can briefly control their response to it, which is perhaps why dark humour can be so powerful.

Changement à vue, – post-tense props for a pre-tense. A joke can be funny and still be horrible, and a joke can be horrible without being funny. And as any Jimmy Carr routine demonstrates, these are not mutually exclusive categories.

Consider a joke about racism. One comedian creates a racist character whose beliefs are exposed as contradictory, ignorant and absurd. Another comedian simply repeats a racial stereotype and waits for the audience to laugh. Both might get laughs, but they’re doing fundamentally different things.

In the first case, racism is the object of ridicule. In the second, the people subjected to racism may be the object of ridicule. This is where the familiar distinction between punching up and punching down comes from, although I’ve always found that expression slightly inadequate. It makes comedy sound like a boxing match in which the comedian must first establish the precise social position of everyone involved before being permitted to throw a punch, – such as their income, ethnicity, education, appearance, are they currently detained at His Majesty’s pleasure?

But the more useful question is surely not simply who is being mentioned in the joke, it’s who, or what, is actually being made ridiculous.

A joke can mention race without making race itself the punchline. It can mention disability without ridiculing disabled people. It can mention gender without treating someone’s gender as inherently amusing. And it can expose the absurdity of prejudice without delivering a lecture about prejudice.

Which is important, because people generally don’t enjoy being told they’re wrong. I’ve noticed this, I’ve conducted extensive research by telling people they’re wrong and observing their reactions. The results have been remarkably consistent. But laughter can sometimes get past the defences that an argument cannot. Tell someone their beliefs are ridiculous and they’ll defend them, but show them those beliefs behaving ridiculously and they might laugh before remembering they’re supposed to agree with them, as for a moment, they’ve seen their own assumptions from the outside.

Of course, this doesn’t mean they’ve changed their mind. People can laugh at a satirical joke and then immediately return to believing the very thing the joke was attacking.

Human beings are perfectly capable of holding contradictory positions, some have constructed entire political careers around it. But comedy can create a brief interruption, a moment in which something previously accepted as normal becomes strange.

Humour often involves putting distance between an event and our interpretation of it. Sometimes that distance is emotional, a terrible event becomes bearable because we temporarily treat it as trivial. Sometimes it’s intellectual, like an accepted belief becomes ridiculous because we suddenly see its contradictions. And sometimes it’s simply a man moving his hands from two feet apart to eight inches apart while discussing the quantity of stuff in the world. In each case, there’s a mismatch between what’s happening and how we’re responding to it.

The joke exists in that mismatch, or at least it might, because we still haven’t established whether something can be funny when nobody laughs.

And I think it can. I think a joke can possess qualities that make it funny to someone capable of recognising them, even if most people don’t, but then that’s exactly what someone whose jokes nobody laughs at would say, for it’s a suspiciously convenient theory. Under this definition, I could spend the rest of my life making jokes that nobody understands, secure in the knowledge that the problem lies entirely with the audience.

“Beep?”
“Beep!”
“Huh? Oh! Sorry, I thought I was still wearing my headphones.”

Anyway, yes, I think I’ve reached a conclusion – humour isn’t simply about laughter, it’s about the sudden recognition that the relationship between things isn’t quite what we thought it was, and the pleasure that comes from noticing. Sometimes that recognition is shared by thousands of people in a theatre, sometimes it’s shared by two people having a conversation. And sometimes it’s experienced by just one person, who’s apparently talking complete nonsense while someone else wonders whether they should call for help.

Which brings me back to the original problem – there’s an enormous amount of humour in the world.

[Holds hands approximately two feet apart.]

Well…

[Moves hands closer together.]

And I think I’ve accounted for most of it.

Did you enjoy this article?

Recommend it — Standard Reader surfaces well-loved writing to more readers across the network.

Across the AtmosphereDiscussions