Why anarchists like James Bond
With all our criticism of the franchise's nationalism and misogyny, we can still enjoy the films and their flawed hero
Yesterday’s article in Freedom caused a stir on publication. When I read it I was determined to write a counter, but in doing so I have to ask myself: why on earth do I enjoy James Bond films?
Some of A. J. Boyer’s criticisms of Bond are sound, so I’m going to try to start with areas where we might find agreement. I should also say that the content of this article includes incidents in the books and films that are offensive. I mention them here to explain in more detail why liking Bond can be more than just problematic.
Around 20 years ago I decided to read Ian Fleming’s original Bond novels. I was shocked by the levels of sexism and racism in the books. On a recent re-read of Live and Let Die the use of the N word and the casual racism through his descriptions of people left me feeling sick. As consumers of culture, we don’t leave our ability to think critically on the shelf when we take the book down to read. We can read something and decide its merits and / or its lack of such. This applies to watching films too. That particular book is disgraceful. You can’t really say it’s just a product of its time. It’s the product of a man who is showing off his racism. A few years ago, elements of Fleming’s work were altered to remove some of the worst offending material. Bizarrely, the alterations didn’t include changing Bond’s reference to having sex with a particular woman as always containing the ‘sweet tang of rape’ and referring to homosexuality as a ‘stubborn disability’. There’s still much to hate about his writing despite the updating and there’s no defence for it.
I won’t include a list of all the disgusting moments in his writing but the levels of it go far beyond what occurs in the films. In the film version of Goldfinger, Bond forces himself on the ludicrously named Pussy Galore. Fleming’s book goes further and describes her as a lesbian. By the end of both the book and the film, Bond and Galore are an item. In the book, Bond has convinced her that her sexuality was an error on her part, so masculine and amazing is he.
Fleming does everyone a disservice in The Spy Who Loved Me by presenting the entire story from a female gaze; something he really isn’t equipped to do. Presented in first person, through the eyes of the character, Vivienne Michel, the novel includes her being confronted by two mobsters who break into her motel with the intention of robbing her and sexually assaulting her. Bond comes to the rescue and she enters a sexual relationship with him. Fleming includes Vivienne explaining how she rejected the brutality of the mobsters but likes the brutality of Bond. It’s another difficult read among many.
So, there’s an awful lot of reasons to dislike James Bond. Not just the character but the original novels in general. The character may be flawed but that shouldn’t mean the novels have to be. But they are. Fleming made them like that and if you tried to remove all the terrible content, some of the novels simply wouldn’t exist.
However, Andrew makes a point that I fundamentally disagree with. He states that “the James Bond franchise presents a character that is so antithetical to anarchist values, that it becomes impossible to take seriously”. Here’s the thing, though: I don’t take the films seriously. I take them as a bit of entertainment. The films are fun, silly and adventurous. The character is utterly ridiculous and horrible. He stands against everything I agree with. But Bond exists in a strange world. It is a fantastical world in many ways. It’s a world closer to science fiction than reality. The laser beam heading to Sean Connery’s crotch in Goldfinger, the invisible car in Die Another Day, Pierce Brosnan using a parachute to surf a tsunami in the Arctic without a jacket of any sort; the list of nonsense in these films is massive.
We should also note that, as the franchise has been going for over 60 years, it also provides an interesting lens to societal views throughout time. The insistence that Timothy Dalton’s Bond only stick to one sexual relationship in 1987’s The Living Daylights is the franchise’s direct response to concerns around HIV and AIDS. In more recent films, Bond is constantly criticised for his behaviour by his superiors. He doesn’t change much, but attitudes around him do. He is a much better flawed hero in the films than in the books, because the books themselves are so flawed.
Fleming could actually write well, which is all the more damning. In action scenes, his use of very short sentences encourages the reader to dart through the action. His descriptive powers are often dense as he shows off his own extensive knowledge of the world. It would be wrong to say that he couldn’t write. It’s just that he wrote some utterly appalling stuff. I don’t want to make a cheap point about Proudhon here but we’ve got some writers like this in our own canon. Interestingly, Fleming didn’t like the violence of the films, in particular the way Bond seems to relish killing people. Prior to the films he wrote From a View to a Kill, which sees the character agonise over being a sniper. It focuses on the process of going from getting that view of the intended victim through a telescopic lens, to then actually pulling the trigger. As the theme song to the film version of Casino Royal puts it, “when you take a life, do you know what you give?” When From a View to a Kill was chosen as inspiration for a film version in 1985, the word ‘from’ was omitted from the title and the subject matter changed. It is a rare moment where Fleming’s Bond is relatable, in a way.
I’m not here to defend Bond as a character and I’m certainly not here to defend Ian Fleming. I’m here to answer the argument that we can’t simply dismiss Bond as entertainment. I agree, we can’t. But we also can’t assume that every anarchist dislikes (or ought to dislike) Bond. We can’t assume that anarchists who do enjoy Bond films are simply consuming this stuff without thinking. As someone who started watching the films from a very young age—prior to the invention of ITV 2—they were a rare treat. We would go to school the next day and whatever had been shown would be the talk of the playground. I grew up with it. I grew up recognising the character was unpleasant.
There isn’t even a quantum of solace for the patriots who believe in Bond’s view of the world, as Briain’s influence fades around them. But I grew up enjoying the adventure, the wonderful music, the sci-fi gadgets, the locations I’ll probably never get to see in person. Those are the reasons I’m excited to see the next James Bond film. I’ll be keeping my critical thinking with me when I watch it.
Did you enjoy this article?
Recommend it — Standard Reader surfaces well-loved writing to more readers across the network.