Skip to content

Trans remembrance & everyday resistance

The transphobes may have won their draconian legislation, but they have lost the culture war

Freedom Press
Nov 20, 20264 min read

n July 2017, the Tory Government announced a public consultation on legal gender recognition in the United Kingdom. It aimed to bring in a system based on statutory declaration, and like many European countries, allow trans persons to obtain a Gender Recognition Certificate on the basis of a statutory declaration. This proposed change was supported by the Labour opposition and was not seen as significantly controversial.

Almost immediately, we witnessed a systematic attack on trans children, starting with claims about protecting them from untested medical inteventions and the outright lie that children under 18 were undergoing surgery. In an important case funded by American anti-abortionists, it was argued that young people aged 15 were too young to fully appreciate the consequence of taking puberty blockers. When the lower court ruled that children under 18 should not be able to receive any medical intervention, The Guardian celebrated this in its editorial as a return to common sense.

The Appeals Court judges ruled it was legal nonsense, undermined Gillick competency, and if it upheld could undermine access to contraception for women under 16 (which is why the anti-abortion brigade funded it in the first place). But by now, rebranded ‘gender criticals’ were up in arms and the damage was done to our community. The transphobes were given new life and more foundations to persecute the Tavistock Clinic for Young People and attacking youth services and schools.

Then came the billionaire author J.K Rowldemort, who got involved and began tweeting transphobia to her millions of followers and funding transphobic hate groups. Then came legal intervention by the now Labour (Blue State) government. For Women Scotland, Sex Matters and the LGB Alliance worked as a mesh to split Trans people off from LGB. Freed from the ideological shackles of Sheila Jeffries radical feminist talking points, these new transphobes could move on to fear mongering and hate not seen since the heady days of the persecution of Martina Navratilova in tennis (herself sadly now a terf)

But these culture-war attacks would have gone nowhere without the State. From Boris Johnson to Rishi Sunak to Keir Starmer, a series of deeply transphobic prime ministers have followed complete with transphobic health secretaries, education ministers and home secretaries. One minister made it illegal for teachers to refer to children in school by their preferred name. An employment tribunal agreed that gender critical employees could legally misgender their colleagues at work. Two health secretaries, one from each party, banned all prescription of hormone replacement therapy and puberty blockers for under 18s. One of them (Wes Streeting) had previously worked for leading LGBTIA campaign group Stonewall and appeared on television to defend trans women as women.

So here we are, today on this Trans Day of Remembrance: a new ‘left wing’ Labour prime minister with a gay defence secretary, a Muslim woman home secretary, a Jewish foreign secretary—honestly it sounds like an American Democrat’s fantasy—yet this government will continue to enable and apply a draconian set of transphobic policies that amount to wholesale segregation and apartheid.

Adult trans people cannot use the toilets or  changing rooms of their gender identity. They will be housed in prison wards, youth offender wings, immigration hostels and hospital wards of their birth sex. They will be searched by police officers, prison officers and immigration officer on their birth sex/ In Wales, all sex replacement surgery has been cancelled despite people waiting for a decade on waiting lists.

Yet resistance persists. I don’t know a single trans person who uses the toilets of their birth sex. And there has yet to be a single reported incident of a venue or organisation forcing someone to leave. The transphobes may won their legislation, but they have lost the culture war they started. Most people see us as just women, men and nonbinary people who are surviving, just like them, in a toxic authoritarian country ruled by death eaters and bigots.

Personally, I’ve not had one woman in the toilets offer me anything other than acceptance.  In those small moments when a woman tells me my dress looks nice in a public toilet, I feel a sense of recognition and solidarity. That gives me hope that out of our remembrance of past possibilities we find the strength and joy to survive and to win.

Did you enjoy this article?

Recommend it — Standard Reader surfaces well-loved writing to more readers across the network.

Across the AtmosphereDiscussions